Ribelle

ribelle-rated

Ribelle

1665 Beacon Street (Brookline)

We love, love, loved the interior of Ribelle. If a room’s aesthetics has any impact on your ultimate enjoyment of what you are about to experience (as far as food is concerned), this one does not disappoint. From the menus clipped to cardboard cut from wine cases to the rustic-meets-urban servingware, it all tread the line of pleasing…just right.

In July we found our way to Brookline, and due to our rather circuitous route there, were extremely pleased to discover that Ribelle makes ordering wine easy on its guests–you pick a number from a list of rather wittily rendered descriptions and then each bottle is presented at your table: Et voila! You didn’t have ponder regions or vintages or stumble over names or varietals in front of your friends. It sounds silly in the retelling but we promise it is perfectly satisfying in the moment. And the service in this case was perhaps the best of our BCC experiences yet. Our waiter was attentive and friendly (and perfectly capable of pronouncing the actual names of the wines we immediately chose to imbibe).

Our Ribelle experience again predated BCC minutes, so we cannot share the exact dishes we consumed. In general, we found our selection of shared first courses interesting, but there wasn’t an “oh, OH” experience in the bunch. I believe a duck liver pate pleased us most. We then shared two pasta dishes–served in large, simple bowls and significant enough in size to split between four. And here, yes, was the reason to return (besides the visual appeal of our surroundings and the wine list): They were fantastic.

Sadly, it was a case of going one more round when we’d already had our thrill of the evening: The dessert wines chosen didn’t please and the dessert itself paled in comparison to its pasta predecessors. Ribelle, so cool in so many ways, couldn’t quite close the deal.

cock-rating-3.5

Sarma

sarma-rated

Sarma

249 Pearl Street (Somerville)

Some of us were experienced in the ways of Sarma, and so we knew, before beginning, not to fall prey to the restaurant’s ritualistic palate tease. (A danger to both body and wallet.) We steeled ourselves at our June meeting, ordering only a few menu dishes for the table (they are all worth trying), fully prepared for the endless parade of delectable little “extras” to prance by, knowing each and every one could be ours (for a price). And that fried chicken? Worth staying up (or waking up) for, every single time.

There also was a dessert-type concoction that involved hot caramel. Need we say more?

The service was not fawning at Sarma; they didn’t neglect us either. The hosts, servers, and bartenders were businesslike and fairly efficient, which honestly seemed somewhat out of touch with the intimacy of the food they served.

Overall, our night at Sarma pleased us, and even if we ended up pushing our taste-bud boundaries a bit and left unsure of where we stood with the staff, we are perfectly ready to go back and see what comes next.

cock-rating-3.5

The Butcher Shop

butchershop-rating

The Butcher Shop

552 Tremont Street (South End)

The first official meeting of the BCC convened 5/15. Minutes were not kept as we were all still distracted by necessary reveling (ie, we had all managed to make and keep a dinner date). Woohoo! Plus, the Club’s intentions were not yet established.

This said, our public assignation at The Butcher Shop should have been a stellar first-time experience, but let us assure you this particular rocket didn’t hit “afternoon delight” expectations. It all looked great, sure, but left you feeling like something was lacking. Our waiter was laissez faire at best and bored with us at worst, despite our ordering the Grande Charcuterie ($98) and displaying an obvious willingness to ingest multiple drinks. As a group we went out on a limb and ordered a dessert that bordered on savory (oh, hell, it was basically a pot pie), and we were not thrilled. This last disappointment, however, we’d be willing to own as a matter of taste (although there were four of us and we all agreed it was…not good).

In the end, we’d go back, but mostly for the meat…does that make us shallow?

cock-rating-3